Punch-up of the pinots (blind-tasting madness part 4)

Julian — Sun, 14 Mar 2010 20:30:54 +0000

Since the well-remembered Silvaner symposium, Wine Rambler full committee meetings have regularly featured a pair of wines with a characteristic similarity (grape variety and vintage, mostly) that we taste without knowing which is which. Is this a sensible thing to do? The detractors of tasting blind argue two things: It favours bolder, more easily understandable wines at the expense of quieter, more refined types, thereby contributing to a levelling of taste and the loss of originality and regionality in wine. It also, in their view, turns tasting wine, which should be about enjoyment and open minds, into a sort of competitive sport. Valid concerns, surely, but we keep finding that without putting your own palate to the test once in a while, you lay yourself open to the twin dangers of preconceived notions and of auto-suggestion ("Label says this has notes of ripe blackberries. Yeah, I think I'm picking them up..."). So we're stumbling on with the blind tastings.

Julian Sunday, 14/03/2010

Domaine Bachelet, Côte de Nuits-Villages, 2005

Julian — Sun, 14 Mar 2010 20:24:42 +0000

Tasted blind, and very subjectively, here.